Sharing and comments

10 comments

  1. Comment by Phil Edwards posted on

    Passkeys are welcome, but they're already mature, well-understood technology, so the real story is cost and delivery.

    One Login is significantly over budget, with completion pushed from 2025 to 2028 and an extra £115m in the first year of that extension alone. Against that, passkeys are predicted to save around £600 a day in SMS?

    Users also still can't sign up with a passkey or remove their password, which leaves the main phishing risk in place.

    Could GDS publish the total cost and staff effort/time to deliver passkeys, broken down by research, design and development.

    • Replies to Phil Edwards>

      Comment by GDS Communications posted on

      Thank you for your comment. GOV.UK One Login is a multi-year programme with a fully approved business case, successfully delivering benefits for citizens and government.

      Our user research showed that there was still confusion around what passkeys are and how they work, as well as technical challenges when devices are lost or changed. Given the varying levels of digital literacy across our user base, we need to introduce passkeys in a way that maintains the accessibility and usability of the service for everyone, regardless of their familiarity with the technology. For these reasons, we still mandate traditional password + MFA on all accounts while passkeys become more familiar to users.

      Thank you for your question about costs. As this request involves gathering detailed cost data, we have referred your enquiry to our Freedom of Information (FOI) team, who will respond to you in due course.

  2. Comment by Peter Seymour posted on

    Signing up for Gov one was a nightmare. Done reluctantly, as at 70 it is mandatory to enable applying for driving licence replacement that can only now be done online. Once you have Gov One you have to repeat the process, including a signature as well as another photo, for a DVLA account and licence application submission. (Signatures are only accepted if the AI can read them, irrespective of your standard legal signature. )
    Ditto the NHS - which has dummy phone numbers and email addresses to force you to go digital. Plus letters saying it will delete my GP health records etc if I don't do so. (refer to Martin Lewis or the Black Belt Barrister for details). My old boss was head of NHS digital and set up the sales teams, so don't tell me they don't sell the health data. It's in the original public business plan on line.
    But I have no ability, (old phone & tech knowledge) to enable me to take a photo and transfer it to my laptop to for sign up. I cannot therefore have a bus pass.
    I simply do not trust the US based IT industry especially mobile phones or AI not to misuse my data, or their claimed security. I will never bank or do anything serious on a mobile phone.
    I have dozens of necessary security passwords etc and want to use a mobile YUBIKEY device, instead of my ageing memory and encrypted spreadsheet.
    Can I do this ? or am I forced to continue to buy the latest smartphone and give away my personal identity and private life to marketing, simply to access my pensions and health services etc.

    • Replies to Peter Seymour>

      Comment by GDS Communications posted on

      Thank you, Peter, for your comment.

      GOV.UK One Login is a UK government service, built and operated by the Government Digital Service. While we expect GOV.UK One Login to become the primary method people access online government services, we recognise that it will not work for everyone. For this reason, all government services that use GOV.UK One Login, including DVLA services, must provide an alternative route for people to access their service. This alternative route is determined by the individual service.

      For more information about DVLA's alternative routes, please contact them directly:
      Telephone: 0300 790 6801 (Monday to Friday, 8am to 7pm; Saturday, 8am to 2pm)
      Online: https://www.gov.uk/contact-the-dvla

      You can also contact the GOV.UK One Login team by webchat, email or phone for help, to report a problem or to provide feedback: https://home.account.gov.uk/contact-gov-uk-one-login

  3. Comment by Roger posted on

    It’s fantastic, the problem is GOV One login isn’t adopted across many major user journeys.

    So while great technical work is being done here - would love to see more work to drive adoption where it matters.

    1) DWP for universal credit, they expect to attend in person with a passport, multiple times.
    2) HMCTS still uses paper everywhere, PDFs, letters.
    3) HMRC has a complicated mix of 2-5 different usernames, passwords and logins.
    4) Local councils applying for disability badges, passports over email.

    What’s the point of adding passkeys if GOV One login doesn’t get adopted for another 10 years

    • Replies to Roger>

      Comment by GDS Communications posted on

      Thank you for your comment. GOV.UK One Login is already being used by more than 250 government services and counting. Over time, GOV.UK One Login will become the single front door to access these services. GDS is actively working with these government services on their delivery and onboarding plans.

  4. Comment by Neil McEvoy posted on

    This seems like a mainly superficial enhancement. Yes, slightly improved login experience.

    But the real problem issue is multiple and duplicated identity systems. For example in Scotland we also have 'ScotAccount' and 'MyAccount'. Passkeys doesn't begin to tackle this type of issue, so what else can we do?

    https://digitalgov.network/fragmented-identity-reality/

    • Replies to Neil McEvoy>

      Comment by GDS Communications posted on

      GOV.UK One Login is being developed to solve the issue you identify. It will become the single sign-on and identity verification front door for accessing UK government and other public services. This will replace up to 300 individual accounts, accessed via 44 different sign-in methods; and will provide a significantly improved user experience. The introduction of passkeys is an important part of that work.

      While you are correct that GOV.UK One Login and ScotAccount are separate services, GDS are in regular conversation with the team responsible for ScotAccount to explore how we could deliver further benefits for users and both governments.

  5. Comment by Jo Clarkson posted on

    Interesting to understand why this was the next most important feature to develop for One Login. Is any consideration being given to how appointees or 3rd party's utilise One Login on behalf of people interacting with government. This is an immediate and known need that is preventing citizens from using government digital services and is forcing them down paper based routes

    • Replies to Jo Clarkson>

      Comment by GDS Communications posted on

      We recognise the importance of delegated access for some users and will continue to work with cross government partners on this topic. Enabling someone to act on another person’s behalf is a complex area that requires establishing authority and level of access.

      While GOV.UK One Login does not currently provide delegated access, we also recognise that some people may simply need help from a trusted friend, family member or carer to navigate the process themselves. To support this, we have published guidance on how someone can safely help another person use GOV.UK One Login: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/help-someone-use-govuk-one-login. Users who need someone to act on their behalf should contact the government service they’re trying to access for more information on available support arrangements.